The newspaper of Italy, seen from abroad
La Veduta — giornale di idee, cultura e affari
Inaugural Edition № 1
World wire
…
← Back to the edition

OPINION

A Law Against Hatred, and the Shadow It Casts on Speech

Editorial Board458 wordsEdition №190Saturday, 21 November 2026 — Edition № 190

This week the Italian Parliament approved a bill aimed at combating antisemitism, and the foreign coverage has been careful and, we think, right to be so. France 24 reports that the law lists some forms of criticism of Israel among examples of antisemitic conduct, and that it will impose neither financial penalties nor criminal sanctions. The Local Italy records the same vote and the same objection from opposition critics, who say the measure could curb free speech rights to criticise Israeli government policies. Both outlets note that the concerns are about expression, not about the offence itself.

We take the duty seriously. A parliament that legislates against antisemitism is answering a real and documented hatred, and nothing in our pages should be read as minimising it. The question the foreign press raises is narrower and more technical: how a state draws the line between hatred of Jews and argument about the policies of a government. That line is not an Italian problem alone; it is being drawn, awkwardly, in several European capitals at once. What the wires report is that Italy has now drawn it, and that the drawing has been contested.

The detail that matters most, and that the coverage supplies, is the remedy. A law without penalties or criminal sanction operates by declaration and by example — it names conduct, it sets a standard, it asks institutions to take note. That is a softer instrument than a penal code, and a softer instrument is easier to defend on free-speech grounds. But a declaration can still chill. When a parliament lists examples, people read the list, and some of them will be more cautious than the law requires. The world's correspondents are right to watch that chilling effect even where no fine is attached.

We would add a point the wires leave implicit. Italy's Parliament is bicameral, and a bill that passes one chamber with contested language will be read closely in the other and in the country. The value of the foreign coverage here is that it holds the text up to a standard the domestic debate can become too heated to apply: does the law punish conduct, or does it describe it? If the former, it will be tested in court. If the latter, it will be tested in argument. Either way, the test is public, and we will report it as the world reports it.

There is a temptation, in a country so often described from outside by its moods, to treat a single bill as a symptom. We would rather treat it as a text, to be read carefully and argued about plainly. That is the discipline the foreign wires impose on us, and it is the discipline we commend to our readers.

Share