The newspaper of Italy, seen from abroad
La Veduta — giornale di idee, cultura e affari
Inaugural Edition № 1
World wire
…
← Back to the edition

CULTURA

New book examines the 1981 attempt on John Paul II's life, reopening questions about Soviet involvement

A Guardian review of 'Killing the Pope' revisits the shooting in St Peter's Square and the Cold War intrigue surrounding the pontiff's assailant

Eleonora Vanzetti407 wordsEdition №181Thursday, 12 November 2026 — Edition № 181

On 13 May 1981, St Peter's Square in Rome filled with more than 10,000 pilgrims gathered to see Pope John Paul II, the Polish pontiff who had captured global attention since his election. According to the Guardian's books section, a new work titled "Killing the Pope" revisits the assassination attempt that wounded the pope that afternoon, examining whether Soviet intelligence orchestrated the shooting or whether the gunman, Mehmet Ali Ağca, acted alone in what some characterised as the work of a disturbed individual.

The question of Soviet involvement has shadowed the Vatican and Cold War history for more than four decades. The Guardian's review engages with the competing narratives that have circulated since 1981—claims of a KGB plot versus accounts of a deranged hitman—and considers what new evidence or analysis the book brings to a case that has been subject to intense historical scrutiny and, at times, conflicting official accounts from Rome and Moscow.

The attempted assassination of John Paul II remains one of the twentieth century's most contested historical events, with implications that stretched far beyond Rome. The Guardian notes that the Polish pope's election in 1978 had already unsettled the Soviet bloc; his visits to Poland and his public opposition to communism made him a symbolic threat to Moscow's grip on Eastern Europe. The shooting in St Peter's Square, therefore, became a focal point for Cold War suspicion and conspiracy theory.

The book's contribution to this historical debate, according to the Guardian's review, appears to centre on weighing evidence about Ağca's motives, connections and possible handlers. The publication of new scholarship on the subject reflects broader international interest in reassessing Cold War history as archives open and declassified documents emerge. For Rome and the Vatican, which has long maintained a complex diplomatic relationship with Russia, the framing of the 1981 attempt—whether as state-sponsored terrorism or individual violence—carries ongoing diplomatic weight.

The Guardian's coverage suggests that the book offers readers a chance to examine the historical record afresh, at a moment when Cold War narratives continue to shape contemporary geopolitics. The shooting's legacy extends to how the Vatican has positioned itself in relation to Russia and Eastern Europe, making the question of the attempt's origins not merely historical but relevant to understanding Rome's current diplomatic posture and the Church's role as a geopolitical actor.

Share