The newspaper of Italy, seen from abroad
La Veduta — giornale di idee, cultura e affari
Inaugural Edition № 1
World wire
…
← Back to the edition

CULTURA

Michieletto's Carmen Returns to Covent Garden, and London Says It Blazes

The Italian director's 2024 staging, moved to Franco's Spain, is revived at the Royal Opera House with Ginger Costa-Jackson in the title role

Eleonora Vanzetti512 wordsEdition №167Saturday, 31 October 2026 — Edition № 167

Damiano Michieletto's Carmen has returned to the Royal Opera House, and the Guardian's critic found the revival in strong voice. Reviewing the production on 30 October, the paper called Ginger Costa-Jackson 'an elemental and powerful Carmen' and a 'smouldering heroine'. The staging is the Italian director's own, first seen in 2024 and now back at Covent Garden.

The Guardian notes that Michieletto sets the drama in Franco's Spain. That is a working decision rather than a decoration: Carmen is usually placed in nineteenth-century Seville, among cigarette-factory women, deserters, smugglers and a bullfighter waiting in the wings. Move the action into a dictatorship and the chorus, the civil guard and the bandits all change meaning. On the review's account, the evening sustains the move.

A staging revived within two seasons is a staging the house trusts. Revivals are the ordinary economy of opera, cheaper than a new production and judged on whether the original idea still stands with a different set of voices in front of it. The Guardian's headline, which places the credit with its heroine, suggests this one does.

The transposition has a logic a London audience can follow without a programme note. Franco's Spain is close enough in memory to need no explanation and distant enough to be safely exotic, and the score itself is unchanged. Whether a concept earns its setting is the question every updated production faces; the Guardian's answer here is that the heat comes from the woman at the centre of the stage rather than from the idea around her.

The title role is a test of stamina as much as of voice. The Habanera, the Seguidilla and the card scene each ask for a different register, and the singer who carries them has to hold a long evening together. The paper's praise for elemental force suggests a performance that works by presence rather than by ornament.

That is the review a revival wants. A first night is judged on invention; a return is judged on whether the thing still functions, and the standard is a different one. The Guardian treats the Spanish setting as a serious reading rather than a stunt, which is the test an updated Carmen has to pass in a city that has seen many such relocations and where critics are quick to say when a concept has eaten the music.

Italian direction is a familiar presence in Europe's opera houses, and it travels in more than one direction. A director who restages a French score in London carries a reading of it into the international repertory, and the notices written there become part of how the production is understood when it moves on again. For readers here the useful detail is less the ovation than the fact that a 2024 staging has held for two seasons.

What none of this settles is the traffic back. Covent Garden's judgement of an Italian director's reading is now part of the record on which such productions travel, and the London notices are written for a public that will mostly not see the Italian houses where the same names work. That asymmetry is the ordinary condition of the culture desk's beat: the work is Italian, the verdict is foreign, and the two are read together only here.

Share