The newspaper of Italy, seen from abroad
La Veduta — giornale di idee, cultura e affari
Inaugural Edition № 1
World wire
…
← Back to the edition

NATIONAL

Pope Leo Casts a Ballot in Chicago, a First for the Papacy

The Vatican said Leo exercised a US citizen's right to vote by post; the Guardian says no pope is known to have done so before.

Antonio Petrella551 wordsEdition №167Saturday, 31 October 2026 — Edition № 167

Pope Leo has voted in the US midterm elections, the first time a sitting pontiff is known to have cast a ballot in any political election at any point in history, according to the Guardian. The Vatican said the pope exercised his right as a US citizen, submitting a mail-in ballot in his native Chicago ahead of next week's midterms, CBS News reported. The Guardian noted that Leo, a US citizen, has clashed with Donald Trump over several issues.

The ballot was cast by post, and the Guardian described it as the first known political ballot for any pontiff. No other item in the wire reported a different account, and neither the Guardian nor CBS said how the vote was squared with the Holy See's long-standing practice of keeping the Church out of partisan contests.

CBS reported the Vatican's framing in procedural terms, saying only that the pope had exercised his right as a citizen. Neither report described which candidates or measures drew his vote, and neither carried anything from the Vatican beyond that framing, which leaves the political reading of the ballot to others.

Dual nationality at the Vatican is not unusual, and it is worth setting out why. Under the arrangements that followed the 1929 Lateran Treaty, Vatican citizenship is generally tied to office and is normally surrendered when the office ends, so a pope commonly retains the nationality he was born with. On that reading, Leo voted in Chicago as an American and reigns in Rome as sovereign of Vatican City State, and the two do not cancel each other out.

The two dispatches differ in where they put the weight. The Guardian leads on the historical first and on the pope's friction with Donald Trump; CBS leads on the Vatican's explanation and the mechanics of the mail-in ballot. Read together they suggest an institution that chose to describe the act as citizenship rather than as politics, and a press corps that read it the other way.

The wire is thinner than the headlines built on it. The Guardian's reference to clashes with Trump is not elaborated: it does not say which issues, over what period, or with what consequence. Nor is there any indication in either dispatch of how the US bishops' conference, the Italian government or the American campaign responded; if such reactions exist, they were not in the coverage consulted here.

What the reports do establish is a precedent, carefully framed. The Guardian's phrasing — the first known ballot by any pontiff — is precise about how firm that precedent was: known is the operative word, the private voting records of earlier popes are not documented, and the paper claims no more than the record carries.

Seen from Campobasso, this is a story told from two capitals, Rome and Chicago, and it arrives in the Italian interior as a question rather than an event. Foreign coverage of the Mezzogiorno's emptying villages has long noted that the parish is often the last institution standing where the school and the post office have gone. Today's dispatches say nothing about how those parishes read the papal ballot — no survey, no diocesan comment, no local reaction — and this bureau will not supply one.

Share