The newspaper of Italy, seen from abroad
La Veduta — giornale di idee, cultura e affari
Inaugural Edition № 1
World wire
…
← Back to the edition

CULTURE

The Guardian Reads Sonia Gandhi's Memoir as an Italian Story

A review of 'Belonging' follows a shy girl from Italy to the centre of Indian politics, and asks what the transplant cost

Eleonora Vanzetti430 wordsEdition №187Wednesday, 18 November 2026 — Edition № 187

The Guardian this week reviewed 'Belonging', the memoir of Sonia Gandhi, and framed it in terms that will interest readers of this desk: the story, the paper writes, of 'the Italian who became kingmaker in the world's largest democracy'. The review describes a shy Italian girl who meets the scion of an Indian political family, falls in love, and is 'transplanted' into a life she had not chosen.

That word, transplant, is the reviewer's, and it does most of the work. The Guardian presents the book as one of the most extraordinary political stories of the age, and its interest lies less in the offices held than in the crossing of two countries and the long accommodation that followed.

For Italian readers the memoir arrives as a document in the literature of departure. Italy's modern emigration is usually told through labour and the south; here the departure is a single woman's, and the destination is not a factory but the drawing rooms of the Indian National Congress.

The Guardian's review notes that Gandhi has broken a long silence with the book, and treats that reticence as part of the subject rather than an obstacle to it. A public figure who said little for decades now sets down her own account, and the paper reads the result as a reckoning with a role she occupied rather than sought.

The Italian angle the review draws out is not sentimental. Gandhi is described as having been born in Italy and married into the Nehru-Gandhi family, and the review's interest is in what that double belonging made possible and what it cost. The Guardian does not present her as an ambassador between the two countries; it presents her as a woman whose origin was, for years, a political fact others used against her.

That is a familiar theme in Italian writing abroad, and it has a particular resonance now. Italy's own public conversation about its diaspora has shifted in recent years from nostalgia to something more exacting: who leaves, who is allowed to return, and what the country owes the people it lost. Gandhi's case sits oddly beside that debate, since her departure was not economic and her return was never the point.

The review is short on policy and long on character, which is a fair description of the book as the Guardian presents it. Readers looking for an account of Indian coalition politics will not find it here; readers interested in how a life gets rewritten when it crosses a border will.

What the Guardian does not do is claim the memoir settles anything about Italy. It is an Indian political book by an Italian-born author, and the paper keeps its focus there. For this desk the value is narrower and real: a major foreign review has taken an Italian life seriously as literature of displacement, and has done so without reducing it to the accident of a birthplace.

Share