OPINION
Europe Looks in Italy's Mirror and Sees Itself
Editorial Board475 wordsEdition №186Tuesday, 17 November 2026 — Edition № 186
The New York Times this week published a essay under a question that has followed Italy for a generation: is this country the model for Europe's future? Its author, writing after more than a quarter-century of watching the continent, argues that Europe's politics have become more like Italy's — unstable, fragmented, with the far right brought in from the cold. The piece is offered as diagnosis, but it reads to us as something older: the habit, common in foreign coverage, of treating Italy as a laboratory in which the rest of Europe may read its prognosis.
We do not dispute the instability the essay describes. Coalition governments that turn over, parties that split and merge, an electorate that rewards novelty and then withdraws its favour: these are features of the Italian system that foreign correspondents have reported for decades, and they are real. What we would add is that the framing carries an assumption the essay does not examine. To call Europe 'Italianized' is to imply that Italy was the deviation and the continent the norm — that there was a stable European model from which Italy strayed, and to which others are now falling.
The past quarter-century offers a different reading. The fragmentation the essay attributes to Italy's influence — the decline of large catch-all parties, the rise of movements that govern and then collapse, the difficulty of assembling durable majorities — has been visible across the continent on its own terms. Proportional systems, regional parties, the erosion of the old centre-left and centre-right: these are European developments, not Italian exports. Italy arrived at them earlier, and perhaps more honestly, because its institutions never pretended to the two-party clarity that others have now lost.
There is a further point the essay touches but does not press. The far right 'coming in from the cold' is described as a European phenomenon with Italian antecedents, yet the Italian experience of that arrival has been more complicated than the phrase suggests. Parties that entered government have often moderated; others have been tested by office and found wanting. The lesson from Rome is not that the far right is ascendant, but that governing tempers movements in ways opposition never does. That is a less dramatic conclusion than the essay's, and a more useful one.
We read the piece, then, with a measure of recognition and a measure of resistance. Recognition, because the instability it describes is familiar and not flattering. Resistance, because the question in its title flatters the observer more than the observed. Europe is not becoming Italy. Europe is becoming what Italy has long been: a continent of shifting coalitions, regional loyalties and parties that must be tested in office. Whether that is a decline or simply the ordinary condition of democratic politics is the question the essay leaves open. We would have preferred it asked.
