OPINION
A Law Against Antisemitism, and the Line It Draws
Editorial Board348 wordsEdition №189Friday, 20 November 2026 — Edition № 189
France 24 reported this week that the Italian Parliament approved a bill aimed at combating antisemitism, and that the bill lists some forms of criticism of Israel among examples of antisemitic conduct. The same report notes that the law imposes neither financial penalties nor criminal sanctions, and that concerns have been raised about freedom of expression and advocacy for Palestinian rights. The Local carried a parallel account, noting that opposition critics say the measure could curb free speech. We take the stated purpose seriously. A law against antisemitism answers a real and documented hatred, and no serious observer disputes the need to name it.
What the foreign coverage fixes on is not the purpose but the boundary. A statute that enumerates examples carries weight beyond its penalties: it tells institutions, universities, editors and platforms what to treat as beyond the pale. When criticism of a government's policies appears on that list, the question is not whether antisemitism exists — it does — but whether the two categories have been drawn with the precision that a free society requires. The absence of criminal sanction does not make the line harmless. It makes it quieter, and therefore more consequential.
We note, too, how the story is being told from outside. The international wires frame the bill as a test of Italy's balance between solidarity and speech, and they will return to it whenever the country's politics are described. That is the burden of legislating in a contested space: the world reads the text as a statement of values, not merely as a statute. A careful drafting would have given Italy a law the world could cite as a model. A loose one gives the world a reference point of a different kind.
Our view is that the measure should be judged by what it does in practice — how it is applied, whom it silences, whether it protects the Jewish communities it is meant to protect without narrowing the space in which foreign policy is debated. The Parliament has drawn a line. The world will now watch where it falls.
