The newspaper of Italy, seen from abroad
La Veduta — giornale di idee, cultura e affari
Inaugural Edition № 1
World wire
…
← Back to the edition

CULTURE

The Vatican's Quiet Collection, and the Question of Return

As Rome prepares to mark 400 years of St Peter's Basilica, the Guardian asks why the Anima Mundi artefacts stay out of the spotlight

Eleonora Vanzetti495 wordsEdition №184Sunday, 15 November 2026 — Edition № 184

The Guardian's art and design desk published a long look this week at a collection most visitors to the Vatican Museums never set out to see. Under the headline 'An unsettling colonial collection', the paper asks whether the Vatican should return items 'gifted' to it by Indigenous peoples, and notes that the question is pressing as Rome prepares to celebrate 400 years of St Peter's Basilica.

The piece is written from inside the queue. The Guardian's correspondent reports waiting four hours to enter the museums, surrounded by visitors fixed on the Sistine Chapel, and turns from that crowd to the artefacts acquired by Catholic missionaries that, in the paper's framing, are staying out of the spotlight during the anniversary.

That is the tension the Guardian draws: a basilica anniversary that will draw the world's cameras, and a collection whose origins the paper describes as colonial, held in the same institution and largely unexamined in the commemorative moment.

The Guardian's argument is not a demand but a provocation. It describes the holdings as an 'unsettling colonial collection' and frames the word 'gifted' in quotation marks, signalling that the paper regards the transfer of such objects as less than a free exchange. The dispatch is built on the writer's own visit rather than on any new announcement from the Holy See, and it does not report a decision, a request or a timetable from the Vatican.

What the piece does supply is context for the anniversary. Four hundred years of St Peter's Basilica is a date that will invite foreign correspondents and cultural journalists to Rome in numbers, and the Guardian is asking in advance which parts of the Vatican's holdings will be on show and which will not. The paper does not say the collection has been hidden; it says the artefacts are staying out of the spotlight, which is a claim about emphasis rather than concealment.

For readers who follow the museum world from outside Italy, the comparison is familiar. The Guardian's framing places the Vatican alongside European institutions that have faced restitution questions over the last decade, though the piece as published does not name specific counterparts or cite a particular government's position. It keeps its focus on the Vatican's own rooms and on the experience of the visitor moving through them.

The cultural stakes are specific to Rome. The Vatican Museums sit inside the city but answer to the Holy See, which means the restitution debate does not map neatly onto the Italian state's own museum policy. The Guardian's article does not explore that distinction, and this dispatch will not invent one; what the paper offers is a question posed to the Vatican as an institution, timed to an anniversary that will be covered as a cultural event as much as a religious one.

What comes next, on the evidence of the Guardian's piece, is attention rather than action. The paper has put the collection into the foreign-press record ahead of the basilica's anniversary, and the coming months will show whether other international outlets take up the question as the commemorations approach. For now the dispatch stands as a critic's essay, written from the queue, asking who the objects belong to.

Share